Heads up: this post has affiliate links, so Manhattan Society may earn a small commission if you buy through them — never at any extra cost to you. I only recommend things I’d tell a friend to buy. Amazon sets prices and stock.
A stemmed water glass is what separates a set table from a casual one — here are 9.
My top pick: Water goblets are the quiet upgrade. Nobody notices them individually, but a table without them looks unfinished.

1. Classic Water Goblet

A plain stemmed glass for water. Shop water goblets set on Amazon →
2. Crystal Goblet

A finer crystal version for formal use. Shop crystal water goblets on Amazon →
3. Coloured Goblet

Tinted goblets for a decorative table. Shop colored water goblets on Amazon →
4. Ribbed Water Goblet

Textured glass to match ribbed stemware. Shop ribbed water goblets on Amazon →
5. Vintage Goblet

A period or thrifted goblet. Shop vintage water goblets on Amazon →
6. Stemless Water Glass

A casual alternative for everyday. Shop stemless water glasses on Amazon →
7. Goblet and Wine Glass Set

Coordinated water and wine glasses. Shop water wine glass set on Amazon →
8. Budget Goblet Set

An affordable set under $30. Shop cheap water goblets set on Amazon →
9. Placement on the Table

Where the water glass actually goes. Shop table setting guide on Amazon →
The bottom line
A plain crystal goblet is the safe formal choice. Coloured goblets are the more interesting option if your plates are plain.