Heads up: this post has affiliate links, so Manhattan Society may earn a small commission if you buy through them — never at any extra cost to you. I only point you toward things I’d tell a friend to buy. Amazon sets prices and stock.
The loafer has quietly become the most useful shoe in a lot of wardrobes — smarter than a trainer, comfier than a heel, and appropriate almost everywhere. Here are 14 styles and the outfits they do best.
My top pick: A classic leather penny or bit loafer in black or rich brown, with a low stacked heel and a slightly chunky sole. It’s the shoe that carries jeans, trousers, skirts, and dresses from September through spring, and a good pair only looks better with wear.
1. The Classic Penny Loafer
A slim leather penny loafer with a low heel is the template — preppy, timeless, and it goes with everything from cropped trousers to a midi skirt. Black or a deep tan. Buy good leather and it’ll last years. Shop penny loafers women on Amazon →
2. The Chunky Lug-Sole Loafer
A thick, treaded sole under a loafer upper adds height, grip, and a bit of toughness that balances softer outfits — a slip dress, wide trousers, a floaty skirt. It’s the version that looks most current. Great for autumn pavements. Shop lug sole loafers women on Amazon →
3. The Horsebit (Bit) Loafer
The gold snaffle across the vamp is the detail that makes a plain loafer look polished and a little bit rich. It dresses up jeans instantly. Keep the rest of the outfit simple and let the hardware do the talking. Shop horsebit loafers women on Amazon →
4. The Platform Loafer
A loafer on a chunky platform gives you a couple of inches of height with a completely flat footbed, so you can wear it all day. It suits cropped trousers and minis where the shoe is on show. Clean lines, not clumpy. Shop platform loafers women on Amazon →
5. The Tassel Loafer
Tassels add a jaunty, slightly academic detail. A tassel loafer in burgundy or oxblood is a lovely autumn shoe with grey flannel or dark denim. A more characterful alternative to the penny. Shop tassel loafers women on Amazon →
6. The Suede Loafer
Suede softens the loafer and makes it look more expensive, especially in tobacco or chocolate. Spray it and keep it for dry days. It elevates a plain jeans-and-knit outfit with no other effort. Shop suede loafers women on Amazon →
7. The Loafer Mule
A backless loafer — loafer front, open heel — is the easy slip-on version for warmer days and quick trips. It’s a little less supportive, so not for long days on your feet. Sleek with cropped trousers. Shop loafer mules women on Amazon →
8. The Chain Loafer
A delicate gold chain across the vamp is a subtler alternative to the horsebit — a bit of shine without the strong Gucci association. Works with jeans and with tailoring. A quiet upgrade. Shop chain loafers women on Amazon →
9. The Colour Loafer
Once you own black and brown, a loafer in burgundy, forest green, or cream is the piece that lifts a plain outfit. It still behaves like a neutral against denim and black. Buy this one third. Shop burgundy loafers women on Amazon →
10. The Loafer with Cropped Trousers
The cleanest loafer outfit: an ankle-length or cropped trouser that ends right at the top of the shoe, showing a sliver of ankle. Add a tucked shirt or knit. Sharp and easy. Shop loafers women on Amazon →
11. Loafers with Jeans and Socks
A straight or wide-leg jean with a loafer and a visible slouchy or ribbed sock is the relaxed, slightly fashion-y way to wear them. The sock is a deliberate choice, not an accident. Keep the sock tonal or a gentle contrast. Shop women’s loafers on Amazon →
12. Loafers with a Midi Skirt or Dress
A loafer under a midi skirt or dress grounds the outfit and makes it walkable, where a heel would be fussy and a trainer too casual. Add a loose sock as it gets colder. A go-to for the shoulder seasons. Shop leather loafers women on Amazon →
13. Loafers for the Office
With tailored trousers and a fine knit, a sleek leather loafer is completely professional and far more comfortable than a court shoe. Black or brown, low heel, minimal hardware. A pair you can genuinely stand in all day. Shop office loafers women on Amazon →
14. Fit Notes: Size and Break-In
Loafers should fit snugly at the heel with a little room at the toe — leather stretches slightly with wear, so a firm fit out of the box is right. Wear them around the house with socks for a few days to break them in. Heel grips help with slipping. Shop loafer heel grips on Amazon →
The bottom line
Start with a classic leather penny loafer in black or brown, then a chunky lug-sole pair for autumn. Between them they cover jeans, trousers, skirts, and the office, and both only improve with wear.